Journerdism

Will Sullivan's guide to mobile, tablet & emerging tech ideas

Bye-bye, bloglines. No thanks, NetVibes. Greetings, Google!

| 4 Comments

Bloglines plumber

(This is all meta mumbo jumbo about my quest for a new, better RSS Feed reader, so feel free to skip it.)

The past week I’ve been going through a major shift in my life — seeking out a new RSS feed reader.

I’ve been a longtime Bloglines user until a week ago when I kept getting internal server error pages on any feed that had more than 120 updates at a time. And loosing all that information just isn’t an option for my go-go lifestyle.

On the recommendation of a few friends, I tried Netvibes and I … really want to like it. But with more than 1,000 feeds, it’s just not very feasible to have 23827993240 tabs and widgets. Also, the speed of feed delivery seemed to be impaired by that massive number of feeds.

So I’m now with Google Reader. Although the interface isn’t totally my cup of tea (I feel like I need a 2400×1600 screen really cruise through my feeds efficiently… ::drool:: 2400×1600 screens… ). The top 1/3 of Google’s interface could really be compacted to show more feeds and less static navigation but I guess most people aren’t digging through hundreds of feeds. I also don’t dig that when I click to add a new feed Google, it always asks me if I want to add it to iGoogle homepage or to Google Reader. Google’s smarter than that. It should remember my selection, stop trying to force your iGoogle voodoo on me, Google! But I can deal with that.

What I really find indispensable is Google’s speed for feed reading. With the two views (expanded showing the whole shabang and list view offering a Gmail-like one line preview) I can wade through my reading in at least half the time compared to Bloglines because everything is so uniform, organized and loaded quickly with everything preloading in the background. The starring and tagging features are increasingly helpful also (as I start to wrap my head around new workflow options).

In general, I always try to support the underdog. And Bloglines has been great to me so far but I have to move on. I’m kinda afraid of having so much my freaking life secretly catalogued by Googlezon, since I use so many of their products throughout my entire day. (I swear by gmail for personal and work email, I use Google docs as my briefcase for just about everything, including blog entires I’m working on, obviously, Google search is big, and now they have my RSS feeds. If only they’d bought Delicious, Google would have basically my entire online life and DNA locked down and mapped out.)

Is there a lesson here for journalism? Well, even when your providing a ‘free’ online service, customers tolerate failure just as much as if they’re paying for it… In fact, I swear I remember Jason Fried from 37signals saying he found customers demand more from a free service than if they’re paying. (I can’t find a quick link to that though, so don’t quot me.)

Any other web-based feed readers you all recommend I check out?

4 Comments

  1. List view. J, J, J, J, shift-S, J, K, J, J …x200… Mark all as read. Works wonders. I still use a few folders for things like my own paper’s RSS feeds so I can see that they’re still working, then quickly mark them as read.

  2. There’s a widget to toss in your bookmark toolbar that will find the feed and skip the Reader v. iGoogle page, and take you straight to Reader to subscribe. I don’t remember where I found it, but it exists.

    I, too, fear all my info being handled by Google, but damn, they do so many things so well.

  3. I’ve found that Web-based feed readers are a fine place to start, and useful for people who tend to read feeds via multiple devices (especially mobile). But their functionality is pretty limited and user interface is generally frustrating.

    Personally, I’ve given up on Web-based feed readers and use NewsFire for the Mac. It’s sophisticated, very user-friendly, and even works fairly well as a podcatcher. It’s not free, but pretty cheap.

    If you must use a web-based feed reader because you’re on multiple devices, especially mobile, you might want to try out newsgator.com. Their online service is good for a feed user with more sophisticated needs. Sounds like you’re way beyond the training wheels stage.

    - Amy Gahran

  4. You guys rock. I’m going to try and find that Google widget, Test out Newsgator and start learning all the keyboard shortcuts!

    Thanks!
    Will

Leave a Reply

Required fields are marked *.

*